Sneaker Kit Face-Off
Tandy Leather vs. Shoemakers Academy:
Choosing between these two kits comes down to one question:
Are you a traditional leather crafter or a DIY shoemaking beginner?
Here is how the Tandy Starter Pack stacks up against the Shoemakers Academy DIY Kit.
| Feature | Tandy Leather Sneaker Starter Pack | Shoemakers Academy Sneaker Kit for Beginners |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $69.99 Shipping: $19.99 | $69.00 Flat rate: $10 |
| Skill Level | Intermediate (Level 4) | Beginner Friendly |
| Training | Written Instructions / Blog | In-depth 4-Hour Video Quick Start Guide Web Page & Blog 72 Page guide book (optional) |
| Build Style | Traditional Leather (Awl & Punch) | Traditional Leather (Awl & Punch) |
| Included Extras | Rubber outsole, Insoles, Pattern must be downloaded | Plastic Pattern, Rubber outsole, Memory Foam Insoles, Waxed Thread Lasting Board, Erasable Pen, Quick Start Shoemaking guide |
| Pattern Types | Low, Mid, and High-top | Low-cut and High-top |
Why Choose
Tandy?
- Best for heavy leather (up to 8 oz).
- Ideal if you already own leatherworking tools.
- Simple Pattern
Why Choose
Shoemakers Academy?
- Best value for beginners.
- Includes a lasting board for better shoe shape.
- Video guidance makes it nearly impossible to fail.
- USA size Men’s and Women’s
Why Not?
- Expensive shipping
- Pattern not included
- Euro sizes only
- Weird heel on outsole
Why Not?
- Longer build time
- More complicated pattern